
Founded as First Baptist Church in 1858, this is the oldest church in Evanston. The current building was built in 1873 by architect Cass Chapman, with a 1920 addition by ThomasTallmadge. The style is Gothic Revival; the original brick is now covered in stucco. In 1984, Evanston’ first shelter for homeless people opened here. In order to get around zoning regulations forbidding homeless shelters, it was labeled an "all-night prayer service."
First Baptist Church was founded by a women, Frances Mary Iglehart. Her sewing machine (pictured here, courtesy of Lake Street Church's Facebook page) served as the first pulpit and communion table, and is still used it on special occasions to honor her legacy.
Photo credits: Lake Street Church 1887 and sewing machine plaque, Evanston History Center archives